When people think of Maine food they often imagine lobster with lots of melted butter and maybe a roll on the side. There are quite a few other things we’re great at, too. Every tried brown bread baked in a can? Or how about a whoopie pie? These are all quintessentially Maine foods that we love. But bagels? Those are usually left to the experts in places like New York. Until now, that is! Food & Wine Magazine recently named their winners for best bagels in American and three local Maine spots made the list!
- Scratch Baking Co, South Portland
Ahmad A / Google
The Willard Square area of South Portland is one of our favorite little corners of southern Maine. With Willard Beach just down the street and tons of adorable little homes, if there was ever a little slice of New England it’s here! Plus, having access to one of the best bagel shops around is a nice bonus.
Karl Morlock / Google
We’re not the only people who think so. As one of the Maine bakeries deemed to have the best bagels in America Scratch Baking Co. is a must-visit if you love starting the day with a great breakfast.
Scratch Baking Co. / Facebook
They’ve got a few different varieties, but we especially love the ones that feature Maine ingredients.
Scratch Baking Co. / Facebook
And before you go, make sure to grab something sweet! This bakery is nothing short of spectacular.
Karl Morlock / Google
- Forage Market, Lewiston
SHARMAN MAHONEY / Google
Walking into Forage is like walking into a hip college coffee shop. The cozy atmosphere is perfect on a chilly Maine day, of which there are many in just about any season!
Alan C / Google
While we love the coffee and their baked goods, Forage may have set the standard for bagels in Maine. With so much success they opened a second location on Washington Avenue in Portland, we’re not surprised they made the Food & Wine list.
Max Davis / Google
This wood-fired bagel is one of the best in the country and it’s perfect with everyone from a simple shmear to an entire breakfast sandwich.
Andrew Paradis / Google
- Rover Bagel, Biddeford
Troy Hollihan / Google
Freshly baked in their ultra-cool Pepperell Mill space, Rover Bagels is a good and simple spot for seriously delicious bagels.
Sandra White / Google
Wood-fired to perfection this bagel won’t be a lot like others you’ve tried. It takes its cues from Anadama bread, a New England tradition. But that doesn’t make it any less scrumptious.
Neal Bangor / Google
Because the flavor is so unique, these bagels are great on their own. But try them as part of a sandwich and your day will be made.
Patrick Byrne / Google
We love them packed with bacon.
Rover Bagel / Facebook
But the lox and cream cheese version has us wondering if our days of heading to NYC for bagels is over for good.
Abby Baker / Google
Have you tried the bagels at any of these spots? If so, what do you recommend? Let us know your favorites in the comments and tell us what else we should be sure to try when we’re there!
Ahmad A / Google
Karl Morlock / Google
Scratch Baking Co. / Facebook
SHARMAN MAHONEY / Google
Alan C / Google
Max Davis / Google
Andrew Paradis / Google
Troy Hollihan / Google
Sandra White / Google
Neal Bangor / Google
Patrick Byrne / Google
Rover Bagel / Facebook
Abby Baker / Google
Scratch Baking Company is open Wednesday through Sunday from 7 a.m. to 1 p.m. Check them out online and on Facebook. You can reach them on 207-799-0668.
Forage Market in Lewiston is open every day from 8 a.m. to 1 p.m. and in Portland from Monday through Friday 7 a.m. to 1 p.m. and Saturday and Sunday 8 a.m. to 1 p.m. Check them out online and on Facebook. You can reach them on 207-333-6840 in Lewiston and 207-274-6800 in Portland.
Rover Bagel is open Wednesday through Friday from 7 a.m. to 2 p.m., Saturday from 8 a.m. to 2 p.m. and Sunday from 8 a.m. to 12 p.m. They’re closed on Monday and Tuesday. You can check them out online and on Facebook. You can reach them on 207-710-6248.
For more award winning baked goods head to Biddeford in southern Maine! Recently named one of the best in the country, Night Moves Bread in Maine is delectable.
OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article.
Address: 416 Preble St, South Portland, ME 04106, USAAddress: 180 Lisbon St, Lewiston, ME 04240, USAAddress: 123 Washington Ave, Portland, ME 04101, USAAddress: 10 W Point Ln STE 10-204, Biddeford, ME 04005, USA
